Microsoft is seeking permission to appeal to the UK Supreme Court after losing its Court of Appeal challenge in the ValueLicensing case—a battle that could determine whether customers have the right to resell their perpetual software licenses. The UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal ruled in 2025 that resale and subdivision of Microsoft on-premise software licenses did not infringe copyright.
ValueLicensing initially sued Microsoft for £270 million in 2021, alleging that Microsoft inserted contractual clauses to nudge customers toward Microsoft 365 subscriptions while preventing them from reselling perpetual licenses. Microsoft then pivoted to argue that reselling its software was copyright infringement—an argument the CAT rejected and the Court of Appeal upheld.
A separate class action bearing similarities to this case could result in a multibillion-pound payout. The case has profound implications for individual and organizational control over purchased technology assets, harkening back to the 2012 EU UsedSoft ruling that affirmed the right to resell software licenses. The stay was partially granted but ValueLicensing’s discovery requests continue, with a case management conference set for September.
Source: The Register | Attribution: The Register
