When the Bot Decides Your Raise

When the Bot Decides Your Raise

Performance review season is here, but the entity evaluating your work might not be your manager. A recent Headway survey, reported by TechRadar, found that a third of managers have used AI to write performance reviews, and over half have used it to script difficult conversations. The appeal for managers is clear: efficiency. The cost to you is a profound erosion of trust and a dangerous power asymmetry.

If your raise or promotion depends on that review, learning that a language model drafted it—or even decided the outcome—strikes at your economic agency. This isn’t hypothetical. A lawsuit against Meta already alleges AI selected workers for layoffs. California’s new ‘No Robo Bosses Act’ tries to stop AI from firing workers, but as analysis of that law shows, its protections are narrow. The AI hiring standoff has simply shifted to AI management.

There is a spectrum between using AI to polish grammar and generating the entire review. The real danger is the lack of transparency. As burnout expert Thalia-Maria Tourikis notes, the “perfection of AI reads as superficial.” When human emotions like trust and empathy are involved, outsourcing the conversation to a machine doesn’t just save time; it strips the feedback of its meaning and undermines the manager-employee relationship. The core question isn’t whether AI *can* write a review, but whether an individual’s career should be decided by a system they cannot question or appeal to. This story breaks just as performance review season begins, making it immediately relevant to the Cogtropolis audience. It directly connects a common workplace anxiety to the broader trend of algorithmic management, following the site’s coverage of the Meta AI layoffs lawsuit and the limits of California’s new AI laws. It highlights a clear power asymmetry where individual economic agency is filtered through unaccountable systems.

Source: Original article